If you’re anywhere near Mount Snow and you don’t stop at Sticky Fingers Bakery, you’re making a mistake. This tiny spot on Route 100 in West Dover has been turning out some of the best baked goods in southern Vermont for years, and the cinnamon rolls alone are worth rearranging your morning around.
The Cinnamon Rolls
Let’s start with what put this place on the map. The cinnamon rolls at Sticky Fingers are enormous – golden, gooey, layered with cinnamon, and topped with a thick cream cheese frosting that somehow doesn’t overpower the pastry underneath. They come out of the oven in the early morning, and if you time it right, you’ll get one still warm. There’s a reason people drive past three other breakfast options to get here first.
Beyond the Rolls
The cinnamon rolls get the headlines, but the rest of the case is just as impressive.
🥐 The butter croissants are legitimately excellent – flaky, buttery, and laminated the way they’re supposed to be. More than one person has compared them to what you’d find in a Parisian bakery, which is not something you expect on a two-lane road in Vermont.
🍞 Sourdough loaves come out on weekends and sell fast. The herb and cheese sourdough is particularly good – crusty outside, tender inside, and it makes the best toast you’ll have all week.
🫐 The blueberry muffins, cherry Danish, and almond croissants round out the display case. They also bake focaccia, enriched breads, and seasonal specials that rotate throughout the year.
Everything is made from scratch. No shortcuts. You can taste it.
Menu Highlights and Pricing
Sticky Fingers keeps the menu tight and the quality high. Expect to spend $4–$7 per pastry, which is reasonable given the size and craftsmanship. Here’s what typically fills the case:
🍩 Cinnamon rolls run around $6–$7 each. They’re large enough to split, though nobody actually does.
🥐 Butter croissants and almond croissants are in the $4–$6 range. The almond version is loaded with frangipane and sliced almonds – more dessert than breakfast, honestly.
🍞 Sourdough loaves go for $8–$12 depending on the variety. The herb and cheese loaf and the classic country sourdough are the most popular. Grab one early on Saturday – they sell out by 10 AM most weekends.
🫐 Muffins and Danish pastries land around $4–$5. The blueberry muffins use real berries, not the fake blue pellets you find at chain bakeries.
There’s no printed menu on the wall – you look at the case and pick what catches your eye. The staff will happily walk you through what’s fresh that morning.
What to Know Before You Go
📍 210 Route 100, West Dover, VT – about 2.5 miles south of Mount Snow
🕐 Open 7 AM – 2 PM, Thursday through Monday. Closed Tuesday and Wednesday.
📞 (802) 464-9463
🪑 No indoor seating – this is a grab-and-go operation. Order at the counter, take your bag to the car, and eat in a parking lot like everyone else does. Nobody minds.
💳 They accept credit cards, but the line moves faster if you have cash ready.
🅿️ Small parking lot out front with room for maybe 8–10 cars. On busy mornings, you might need to park along the road shoulder – it’s safe and everyone does it.
The bakery is small and popular, especially on weekend mornings during ski season and peak foliage. If you want the full selection, get there early. By mid-morning, the best items are gone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Do I need to get there right at 7 AM?
A: It helps during peak weekends (i.e., ski season, holiday weekends, foliage). On a regular Thursday or Friday, you can roll in at 9 AM and still have plenty to choose from.
Q: Can I order ahead or call in a special order?
A: They sometimes take pre-orders for large quantities – call (802) 464-9463 to ask. For a regular visit, just walk in and pick from the case.
Q: Is Sticky Fingers good for kids?
A: Absolutely. Kids go straight for the cinnamon rolls and muffins. It’s quick, there’s no sit-down wait, and you’re in and out in a few minutes. A perfect first stop before heading to the mountain.
Q: Do they serve coffee?
A: They have basic drip coffee, but if you want a proper espresso drink, grab your coffee at Village Roost or 1 MTN and bring it with you. The pastries are the star here.
Our Take
We send every guest to Sticky Fingers. It’s one of the first things we mention in our Valley View Villa welcome guide, right alongside the best coffee spots near Mount Snow. The drive from the house takes about five minutes, and we’ve never had anyone come back disappointed.
If you’re planning a morning in the area, grab pastries at Sticky Fingers, coffee at Village Roost or 1 MTN, and you’ve got yourself a breakfast that beats any sit-down restaurant within 20 miles. Just don’t skip the cinnamon roll. You’ll regret it.
